Is your repair quote fair?
Is this used car a money pit?
Get the verdict before you sign.
RepairPal prices one repair. CarFax shows the car’s past. Reddit gives opinions. A Verdict reads your whole shop quote line by line against your exact VIN, runs the repair-to-value math, and gives you one call — fix, defer, walk, or buy — with a sourced receipt under every claim. One email. About 15 minutes. Paid once, by you, never by a shop.
From your VIN to your inbox, in one picture.
- 17-character VIN
- Current mileage
- ZIP code
- Symptoms (free text)
- Service history (when disclosed)
- Shop quote PDF (Full)
- Up to 10 photos (Full)
- 01 VIN decode + scope check
- 02 Recall + ODI cross-reference
- 03 TSB + extension scan
- 04 Platform reliability normalization
- 05 Mileage-band ceiling + floor calc
- 06 Climate cohort adjustment
- 07 Failure-mode pattern match
- 08 Quote line-item autopsy (Full)
- 09 Photo-vs-line evidence check (Full)
- 10 Cost-asymmetry + cascade model
- 11 Repair-to-value math
- 12 Four-lens self-check audit
- 13 Verdict band + prose render
- 0–100 Verdict Score + band
- Plain-English recommendation
- Line-by-line analysis
- Open recall report
- Complaint pattern cross-ref
- TSB lookup
- Coverage hunt receipts
- 12-month roadmap
- Repair-to-value math
- Pre-purchase decision (when applicable)
- Shareable PDF
- Permanent audit-trail UUID
Same inputs always produce the same Verdict. The audit trail is stored with every adjustment so the call is reproducible for life.
Where the receipts come from
Every open safety recall on your exact VIN. Surfaces the official remedy and whether the dealer will fix it free under the recall.
Open recall count, recall name, NHTSA campaign ID, remedy text, dealer-eligible flag
Over three million owner-reported complaints, normalized by year / make / model / mileage so we can tell you which patterns are real and which are noise.
Complaint counts, top complaint clusters, mileage windows, severity ratios
The repair-pattern documents manufacturers send to dealer technicians. Your shop reads them internally. We read them for you, by VIN.
Bulletin IDs, condition, corrective action, applicable VIN ranges
Customer Satisfaction Programs and warranty extensions that quietly cover specific components for years past the bumper warranty.
Program name, eligible VIN range, covered component, expiration window
The federal database that turns your 17-character VIN into make, model, trim, body, engine, transmission, plant, and model-year-corrected build data.
Year, make, model, trim, engine cc/cyl, drivetrain, body class, manufacturer
270 platform-specific failure patterns documented from service-manual literature and verified pattern reports. ICE, diesel, hybrid, and BEV across the major US platforms.
Component, expected mileage window, severity, downstream-damage path, fix cost band
Forty platforms and ninety-three engines with mileage-band reliability profiles. The baseline against which your specific vehicle is scored.
Expected reliability curve, mileage-band severity ceilings, platform tier
Rust-belt salt exposure, desert heat cycling, coastal humidity, mountain altitude — climate changes which failures actually matter.
Cohort tag, rust-belt multiplier, heat-failure adjustments, applicable findings
What a fair price actually is for this exact repair, this region, this shop tier. Independent vs. dealer vs. franchise quoted separately.
Parts $, labor hours, dealer-vs-indy spread, regional adjustment factor
Your car’s ZIP-code-level market value — so repair-vs-replace math reflects what your car is actually worth where you live, not a national average.
Trade-in value, private-party value, regional adjustment, mileage adjustment
What it costs to do the work now versus what the downstream damage costs if you skip it. Catalytic converters, transmissions, timing chains — the cascade math is the same math your shop does silently.
Now-cost band, defer-cost band, escalation probability, cascade severity
Salvage, rebuilt, flood, lemon-law buyback, frame damage — the ceiling-setting findings that cap how high any Verdict can score regardless of mechanical condition.
Title flags, structural ceiling, frame-damage flag, accident-history weight
When you upload a shop’s inspection PDF, every line is extracted, normalized, and scored. Up to ten attached photos are pulled and described for visual context.
Line items, severity tags, recommended-action verbs, photo metadata
What a recall finding looks like
Front passenger airbag inflator — Takata Alpha
Your VIN sits inside the highest-risk Alpha population — this is a Do-Not-Drive-class defect that the dealer is required to fix free of charge regardless of mileage or ownership history. Book the recall before any other passenger-side dash or HVAC work — the glovebox has to come out either way, and sequencing this first saves you a second labor visit. Ask the service writer: “Please run my VIN against campaign 19V-502 and schedule the Alpha inflator remedy at no charge.”
NHTSA recall APIOpened
Aug 2019, no expiryRemedy
Component replacementOut-of-pocket
$0 (dealer-covered)
What the engine checks on your vehicle
- VIN decoded to year, make, model, trim, drivetrain, plant
- Engine, transmission, displacement, configuration
- Body class, gross weight rating, restraint type
- Production date window vs. recall-affected ranges
- Current mileage normalized against platform reliability curve
- Mileage-band failure ceilings (what is “normal” for your platform here)
- Wear-class adjustment: highway, commuter, fleet, garage queen
- Ownership chain context if disclosed
- ZIP-code cohort: urban, suburban, rural
- Climate cohort: rust-belt salt, desert heat, coastal humidity, mountain
- Regional valuation adjustment
- Regional repair-cost adjustment
- Free-text symptom description parsed and matched to failure-mode patterns
- Recent service work disclosed (when applicable)
- Body-and-structure section: accident history, panel replacements, rust, frame
- Powertrain-aware questions for BEV / PHEV / HEV / diesel / ICE-turbo
- Title-status ceiling (salvage, rebuilt, flood, lemon-law buyback)
- Structural-finding ceiling (frame damage caps how high any Verdict can score)
- Open-recall floor (an open safety recall floors the recommendation pace)
- Coverage floor (active warranty extension on a flagged component changes urgency)
- Up to ten attached photos parsed for visual context
- Each described to the engine in natural language
- Visual-evidence flags surface when a finding contradicts shop language
- Photo source noted on the relevant line in the report
Your shop’s quote, line by line
Upload your shop’s inspection PDF or paste the quote text on a Full Verdict and the engine runs an eight-pass autopsy on it. Every pass is documented in the report so you can show your shop exactly where each call came from.
Each recommendation on the inspection or quote gets its own severity rating, its own timing call (now / soon / monitor / skip), and its own one-paragraph rationale. Nothing gets quietly bundled into a single “needs work” verdict the way shop estimates often do.
Parts and labor on each line are compared to the regional baseline for an independent shop versus a dealer. We do not pretend dealers should cost the same as the indy down the street — we report both spreads.
When a line replaces a component that should be tested first (alternator, coil pack, oxygen sensor), the Verdict flags it as a diagnostic shortcut and tells you the specific discriminator test that should have come first.
Diagnostic fees, scope-of-work, “recommended” items, and customer-pay add-ons are separated from the actual mechanical repair you came in for. You see which dollars are doing the work.
When two lines bill labor for the same teardown (cam cover gasket + valve adjustment, for example), the overlap is called out. When a maintenance line is being sold as a repair, that is called out too.
If the shop is quoting a repair that NHTSA already classifies as a covered recall or that a manufacturer TSB tells dealers to handle differently, the Verdict surfaces the receipt by VIN.
On a Full Verdict, attached photos are read against the line they support. If a photo shows a healthy gasket but the line bills for one, it gets flagged. If a photo shows a real leak, the urgency rises.
The Verdict adds up what you actually need now, what can wait, what to skip, and what dealer-eligible work is on the list. You leave knowing the dollar number to authorize today.
What one quote line looks like, autopsied
“Replace alternator and serpentine belt” — $612
The unit price is fair for an OEM-grade Denso reman on this platform. The problem isn’t the bill — it’s that nobody confirmed the alternator is actually bad. That confirmation runs ten minutes and costs about $25 of shop time. Skipping it is how a $25 test becomes a $612 part you may not need. Say this verbatim at the desk: “Before we replace the alternator, can you print the voltage-drop reading at the battery posts under load, plus the parasitic-draw amperage with everything off?” If the numbers fail spec, authorize. If they pass, the real failure is a battery or a parasitic load. Belt swap at 78k is on-schedule — keep that line.
$310–410Labor (indy, 1.4 hr book)
$140–210Quoted
$612 · fair IF neededPace
TEST FIRST
Got a quote sitting on your kitchen table right now?
Get a Full Verdict — $129Buy this car, or don’t — the four-decision tree
On a pre-purchase Verdict, the engine adapts. The same data sources fire but the output is built around one question: should you actually buy this specific car? You get a clean four-decision call with the receipts.
What a buy/don’t-buy call looks like in full
Bones look sound but two pattern flags sit inside your decision window. The EX-L runs the 6-speed with VCM (Variable Cylinder Management) — and the documented cylinder-deactivation judder on this combo starts showing up between 80–110k miles. Insist on a 15-minute road test in 5th and 6th gear at part throttle, 35–55 mph. If you feel a steady-state vibration like a slipping clutch, walk. If it’s clean, negotiate $1,800 off — the timing belt + water pump on the J35 hits its 7-year age threshold this year regardless of mileage, and that service runs $1,400–1,900 on this platform.
22%
2
1
Looking at a used car right now?
Get a Quick Verdict — $79Fix it, sell it, or let it go
When a car is on the edge of “is it worth it,” the Verdict runs the full economic picture. Not just the quoted repair, but the next twelve months, the trade-in math, and the replacement-budget question.
What you would spend to fix what is actually broken now, divided by what your car is worth in your ZIP. The ratio is the spine of every repair-vs-replace decision.
Your platform’s documented failure-mode pattern at your mileage is folded in. The forecast tells you what else is statistically due in the next twelve months — so today’s repair is not the only number in the math.
If you’re moving on, the Verdict compares the net you would clear by listing as-is against the net after the repair. Sometimes the repair pays you back at sale and sometimes it does not.
Trade-in offers, private-party offers, and instant-cash-offer numbers each get separate value bands so you can see which exit door makes the most sense.
When a car is past the walk-away threshold, we name the realistic floor — what you actually get from salvage or a parts-out — instead of leaving you to negotiate against a zero.
If the math says move on, the Verdict closes with a realistic next-car budget anchored to what you would clear from this one. So you do not walk into a dealership with the wrong number in your head.
Repair-to-value under your floor, no ceiling effects in play, no looming cascade failure inside the next twelve months. The Verdict lists what to authorize today and what to defer with no penalty.
Repair-to-value over the threshold, plus a documented pattern about to fire, plus diminishing valuation. The Verdict prints the trade-in and private-party bands and a realistic replacement budget.
Coverage your dealer won’t mention unless you ask
Coverage you may already own — but cannot see unless someone runs your VIN against the right registries. The Verdict does this on every report.
Specific extensions issued by the OEM past the bumper warranty — common on emissions hardware, hybrid batteries, infotainment, transmissions, and tow-package components.
The quiet programs OEMs use to fix known issues without a public recall. The dealer will not bring them up unless you do.
Every open recall on your VIN with the official remedy and dealer-eligible flag. The Verdict tells you exactly what to ask the dealer to do free of charge.
When a component fails just past warranty on a known platform issue, manufacturers often authorize partial-pay goodwill. The Verdict names the program and the phrasing that opens it.
What you can do — and where each other route falls short
Other ways to answer the same question — and where each one actually stops short. We’re not the only option, but we’re the only one with no financial interest in the work you do or don’t do.
| Feature | RepairVerdict | Second-opinion shop | Vehicle-history report | Dealer service writer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Independent of repair revenue | ||||
| Per-VIN open-recall lookup | ||||
| TSB + extension cross-reference | ||||
| Owner-complaint pattern at your mileage | ||||
| Line-by-line quote autopsy | ||||
| Coverage hunt (CSPs, goodwill) | ||||
| Repair-to-value math | ||||
| 12-month maintenance roadmap | ||||
| Pre-purchase buy/don’t-buy call | ||||
| ~10-minute turnaround | ||||
| Cost | $79–129 once | $50–150 dx fee, then repair markup | ~$40 | $0 — paid in repair markup |
Twelve deliverables, one email, ~15 minutes
One email. About ten minutes after payment. Inside it, twelve discrete deliverables — every one data-backed, every one sourceable to one of the wells in §1.
The honest disclaimers
A Verdict is decision-grade analytical work. Hands-on testing (compression, leakdown, scan-tool, road-test) still happens at a shop. We tell you which tests to ask for, and why.
We do not take shop kickbacks, do not steer you toward a partner, do not run an “in-network” list. The recommendation is the recommendation.
We flag eligible coverage programs and surface the receipts. The actual approval call sits with the dealer or the manufacturer. We give you the phrasing that gets you in the right door.
One Verdict, one fee. $79 Quick or $129 Full. No recurring charge, no upsell email sequence, no marketing list rental.
Built by a mechanic, for car owners.
Hey — I’m Devon Smith. I ran a large vehicle restoration shop until a critical motorcycle accident took me off the floor and closed the shop. Years of writing estimates, fighting with warranty adjusters, and watching customers nod through repairs they didn’t need rearranged how I thought about the whole industry. The same conversation kept happening — friend or family member gets a quote, doesn’t know if it’s fair, texts me for a gut-check. I’d run their VIN, look up the CSPs and recalls, check the regional baseline, give them the number. Free. Ten minutes. Saved them four figures more times than I can count.
When the accident closed the shop, I had time to build the tool I wished a customer had handed me every time they walked in. RepairVerdict is that conversation, automated. The engine does what I did — only it does it for everyone, in about ten minutes, for $79 or $129.
If a Verdict ever feels off to you, I read every refund request myself. devon@repairverdict.com.
— Devon Smith, founder
Stop guessing. Get the call in writing in about 15 minutes.
$79 if you have a symptom or a pre-purchase question. $129 if you already have a shop quote in hand. Same engine on both — the $129 just gets your shop’s paperwork autopsied too.
If a Verdict isn’t worth what you paid, I refund it. Seven days, no script, no support hoop. Email me the PDF and the reason it missed and I’ll process it same business day. You keep the Verdict. — Devon
Apple Pay, Google Pay, credit/debit accepted via Stripe.